Sunday, September 18, 2011

PSA: The Need for Systemic Change Should be the Real Call for Awareness in the Upcoming (dreaded) "Pinktoberfest"


Executive Director Karuna Jaggar
By Karuna Jaggar, Breast Cancer Action Executive Director

In anticipation of National Breast Cancer Awareness Month this October, Susan G. Komen for the Cure’s CEO Nancy Brinker is calling for “less talk, more action” on breast cancer. I am struck by how similar the urged “action” looks to what the organization has been advocating for years. Komen’s “take action” emphasis continues to be on individual women getting annual mammograms.

At Breast Cancer Action, we bring a markedly different understanding of what action we all need to take—for ourselves, each other, our mothers, daughters, and granddaughters—to truly end the breast cancer epidemic. Komen’s faith in mammograms to bring the “end to breast cancer” is misplaced.

Mammograms don’t prevent breast cancer; they detect breast cancers that have already developed.

Mammograms don’t detect all breast cancers: according to the National Cancer Institute, “mammograms miss up to 20 percent of breast cancers that are present at the time of screening.” (In my situation...Invasive Lobular Carcinoma is not detected by mammograms - prior to my stage III diagnosis done via biopsy and MRI, my mammograms "detected" my 6.2 cm cancer tumor as "fibrous breast tissue - only.)

And unfortunately, there are plenty of women diagnosed, by mammography, with early stage breast cancer who end up dying of breast cancer.

More women getting more mammograms is not going to end the breast cancer epidemic. Neither, of course, are healthy diets and good exercise regimes. (I am woman who has been physically active all my life - dance 14 yrs; martial arts (29 years and counting); hiking; running; weight training; yoga, etc. I have also been a fruit, veggie and mostly pescetarian eater my adult life - and a vegetarian for 4 years in my youth.)

One of the ugly truths of breast cancer is that more than half of all breast cancers have no known cause and scientific evidence suggests that many cases are linked to exposure to environmental toxins. (This is the perspective and approach of my current naturopathic doctors - see "Recommended Provider" page.)

This means that, even if a woman follows Ms. Brinker’s call to exercise, never smoke, reduce alcohol consumption, and control her weight, she may still get breast cancer. (I have never smoked. My alcohol consumption leveled off to a "glass and half" in my early 20s. My top non-pregnant weight has been 105.)

Today the greatest risk for breast cancer is being a woman. In fact, a woman today has a 1 in 8 lifetime risk of getting breast cancer, up from 1 in 20 in the 1960s and 1 in 14 in the 1980s. (In short, there is no medical stereotype for breast cancer!)

We need actions that benefit the health of all women, not just ourselves.

  • Action that does not assume synthetic chemicals are innocent until proven guilty.
  • Action that begins with corporations and extends to our state and federal regulatory systems.
  • Action that addresses the fact that too many women lack the health insurance of Ms. Brinker’s audience.
  • Action that turns the tide on the inequities that mean African American women are more likely to die from breast cancer than their white counterparts.

Action that produces more effective, less toxic treatments, including for metastatic disease.

We need meaningful action to turn the tide of the breast cancer epidemic so fewer women are diagnosed with the disease and fewer women die from breast cancer. We will continue to take action to bring the systemic changes that will end the epidemic.

So if you are going to don the Pink Ribbon and run with the herd this coming October - do yourself and your loved ones a favor and be truly aware.  

1 comment:

  1. Thank you for reposting this! We love your blog at Breast Cancer Action.